What Is Underwriting in Real Estate? An Investor’s Guide

Investing in commercial real estate is a great way for busy, high-income professionals to diversify their portfolios and earn passive income. Who doesn’t want extra sources of money coming in, right?

However, it’s important to understand the numbers behind the deal, especially if you’re a first-time investor. 

It almost feels like every real estate syndication deal out there comes with the promise of double-digit returns for investors. Sponsors are often quick to highlight these potential high yields, making it a common theme in the world of real estate investments.

Want to learn more about syndications? Check out this video:

For instance, you might come across what seems like a solid opportunity, but without a seasoned sponsor to steer the ship, those promising returns might not materialize as you’d hoped.

That’s why, in this article, we’re going to unpack how to thoroughly analyze various commercial real estate deals by taking a deep dive into the underwriting process.

Key Takeaways

• Underwriting in real estate involves assessing the creditworthiness of borrowers and evaluating properties’ value.
• The process plays a significant role in determining the viability of loans, investments, and insurance products.
• Underwriting promotes trust and stability and reduces risks for lenders, investors, and insurance providers.

Join the Passive Investors Circle

What is Underwriting in Real Estate?

When we talk about “real estate underwriting,” it can mean a couple of different things.

#1. First off, it’s the process where sponsors (GPs) and passive investors (LPs), look over and evaluate potential deals.

Related article: GP vs LP In Real Estate Syndications: What’s The Difference?

It’s kind of like doing your homework before jumping into any investment. We’re talking about digging deep into the details and understanding the risks and rewards – all part of making an informed decision.

#2. Now, the second meaning of “real estate underwriting” gets a bit more technical. Commercial real estate underwriting is essentially a deep dive into whether an investment in a commercial property makes financial sense and what kind of risks are involved.

It’s all about scrutinizing different aspects like how much income the property could generate, market conditions, the property’s condition, and the financial health and history of the borrower. 

When an underwriter weighs these factors, they’re not just looking at the property itself. They’re also considering the borrower’s financial track record and the bigger picture of market trends.

In today’s economic landscape, thorough CRE loan underwriting is more important than ever. It’s the safeguard to ensure that loans are given out in a way that’s both responsible and sustainable, making sure borrowers aren’t biting off more than they can chew.

---

---

Why Underwriting Is Important In The Commercial Real Estate Process

Underwriting is pivotal in real estate transactions by safeguarding the lender’s and borrower’s interests. It is essential for several reasons:

• Risk assessment: Underwriting helps lenders measure the potential risk of granting a loan by evaluating the borrower’s ability and likelihood to repay the loan.
• Loan terms determination: Based on risk levels, underwriters can establish reasonable loan terms, such as interest rates and down payment amounts, that suit both the borrower’s capability and the lender’s appetite for risk.
• Market stability: Responsible underwriting practices contribute to the overall health and stability of the real estate market by mitigating the chances of loan defaults and subsequent foreclosures.
• Borrower protection: The process helps you as a borrower ensure you aren’t taking on a financial burden beyond your means. A thorough and fair underwriting process can help prevent you from entering into an unmanageable or unfavorable loan situation.

What Is The Role Of A Commercial Real Estate Underwriter?

The underwriter in real estate conducts in-depth risk assessments to determine the creditworthiness of potential borrowers. They examine various elements, including applicants’ financial status, credit history, employment history, and the property’s market value. This helps them ensure that the borrowers represent themselves truthfully and that the deal is financially sound.

Risk Management

An important component of an underwriter’s role is managing risk. They meticulously evaluate the following:

• Applicant’s credit scores: Higher credit scores indicate a lower-risk borrower.
• Debt-to-income ratio (DTI): This represents the proportion of an applicant’s income dedicated to debt repayment.
• Loan-to-value ratio (LTV): The percentage of the loan amount compared to the property value.
• Property appraisal: A professional appraisal determines the market value of the property.

Join the Passive Investors Circle

How Commercial Real Estate Underwriting Works

Think of underwriting as your financial predictor in the commercial real estate scene. It gives you a glimpse into the future cash flow potential of a property.

As previously discussed, the borrower and the asset they intend to purchase are carefully examined during this pre-purchase phase. 

Title Search

Underwriting isn’t just about getting a property appraisal; it digs deeper. Underwriters do their due diligence by checking the property’s title to ensure no unexpected names are on it.

They also assess if the location is prone to natural disasters like floods or fires, which could ramp up the lending risk. It’s all about leaving no stone unturned.

Underwriting an Existing Property 

When real estate sponsors are contemplating investing in an existing property, they’ve got a bit of an advantage. They can evaluate its past performance, giving a clearer picture of what to expect under their management.

It’s like having a sneak peek into its history, which can reveal a lot about potential vacancy rates and tenant habits. Key things to consider include:

They have a sneak peek into its history, as they’re able to access information about potential vacancy rates and tenant behavior, such as:   

• The likelihood of a tenant renewing their lease once it’s up.
• When the current tenants’ leases are set to expire during their ownership period.
• The expected costs (tenant upgrades, leasing fees, and downtime) to keep the current tenant in the property or get the space re-leased.
• What the market rents might look like when the existing leases run out.

What Are the Most Important Underwriting Inputs for Commercial Real Estate Loans? 

The underwriting process is a complex mix of various elements and analyses, but there are a few that stand out. By diving into these key factors, the sponsor and their lender can make educated guesses about how the prospective property will perform.

The reliability of these assumptions is a big deal – they will tip the scales between a booming success and a disappointing flop in your real estate venture. That’s why it’s so important to remain conservative with these estimates.

Entry and Exit Cap Rate 

In the world of real estate investing, the prices you buy and sell at are some of the main factors influencing your return on investment (ROI). One crucial metric is the property’s entry capitalization rate, or “cap” rate for short.

You figure this out by taking the property’s net operating income in the first year and dividing it by the expected purchase price. 

Cap Rate = NOI/Purchase Price

To nail down whether the property’s cap rate is right on track, it’s essential to compare it with recent sales of similar properties. This comparison gives you a solid baseline.

What’s more, the entry cap rate isn’t just useful initially – it also sets the stage for the exit cap rate. When it’s time to sell after your investment period, the underwriter uses the exit cap rate to determine the right sales price.

Getting this right is key to making your investment work for you.

As an investor, you should anticipate the cap rate to rise 2-3% for the investment duration.

Vacancy Rate 

When you’re investing in a multi-tenant property, it’s pretty much a given that there will be some vacancies over time. That’s why the underwriting model must include a vacancy line item – it’s all about being prepared for this.

The vacancy rate you factor in depends on many things like the:

• type of property
• tenant quality
• number of units
• where it’s located
• supply and demand
• overall economic climate

Keeping an eye on these elements helps you set a realistic vacancy assumption for your investment.

Minimizing Vacancy in Real Estate

Physical vacancy, which is basically how many units are empty, directly impacts the property’s gross rental income and its ability to cover operational costs.

That’s why keeping vacancies low is key. In a value-add investment, where the property is improved to boost its value, you might see a higher vacancy rate at the start.

Related article: Is Value-Add Real Estate a Good Investment Strategy?

But as it’s repositioned and improved, this rate should gradually decrease and stabilize. It’s all about striking that balance to keep the investment profitable.

A good rule of thumb is to aim for a stabilized vacancy rate that’s about 5% to 10% of the property’s gross rental income. Any significant variation from this should be supported by as much information as possible. 

Rent and Expense Growth 

Inflation is shaped by many factors, including economic conditions, the property’s location, seasonality, and the balance of supply and demand. In commercial real estate, inflation usually has a favorable impact.

As the overall cost of products, services, and living expenses rises, so does the ability to increase rent and utility charges for the property. However, it’s important to note that the operating expenses associated with the property also tend to rise with inflation.

This scenario requires a careful balancing act to ensure that the returns from the property keep up with these escalating costs.

Forecasting Costs

When it comes to forecasting operating costs for a property, some are easier to predict than others. Take maintenance and landscaping, for example – you can often lock in these expenses over an extended period through contracts.

However, costs like property taxes and insurance premiums are less predictable. Generally, a safe bet is to assume that both revenue growth and expenditure growth will increase by 2% to 3% annually. This estimation helps in planning and managing the property’s finances effectively.

Financing Terms 

Familiarizing yourself with the jargon of investment real estate is always a smart move, especially since the terms of a commercial real estate loan can change over time.

It’s important to have a good grasp of all the loan specifics, such as the interest rate, term length, amortization, loan-to-value ratio (LTV), and the total loan amount.

Understanding these elements is key to effectively forecasting the cost of the debt associated with the property.

Capital Expenditures Reserves 

As time goes by, every property experiences some wear and tear, leading to the inevitable need for repairs and replacements. To avoid these unforeseen costs, it’s common practice to allocate a part of the property’s monthly income for capital expenditure reserves.

The specific amount set aside can vary based on the type and size of the property. For instance, a multifamily apartment building typically budgets around $250 per unit each year to cover these expenses. This proactive approach helps in maintaining the property’s condition and value over time.

What To Expect During The Commercial Real Estate Underwriting Process

The commercial real estate underwriting process can feel like a journey into uncharted waters, and it does vary a bit from lender to lender. But there’s a general roadmap you can expect.

First off, there’s the initial review of the loan application and all the paperwork that comes with it. Then, the underwriter appraises the property, putting a value on it.

After that, they’ll evaluate the borrower’s credit history and financial status. Finally, the decision on whether or not to approve the loan take place.

This process can be a bit complex and time-consuming, but it’s a critical part of the lending process helping to make responsible loan decisions.

If you’re one of the borrowers, teaming up with a seasoned lender can make all the difference in smoothing out the journey and landing the best terms for your loan.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do underwriters assess risk in real estate transactions?

Underwriters assess risk in real estate transactions by analyzing various factors related to the borrower and the property. This includes the borrower’s credit history, employment status, income, debts, and financial stability. They also evaluate the property’s value, location, condition, and market trends. By considering these factors, underwriters can determine the likelihood of the borrower meeting their loan obligations.

What role does underwriting play in the process of obtaining a mortgage?

Underwriting plays a crucial role in the mortgage process. It serves as a risk assessment tool for lenders to evaluate the potential borrower’s ability to repay the loan and the property’s worth. The underwriting process involves reviewing the borrower’s financial information, credit history, and property details. Based on this assessment, lenders can decide whether to approve mortgage applications and determine the loan terms, such as interest rates and down payment requirements.

Can the underwriting stage impact the timeline of a real estate closing?

Yes, the underwriting stage can impact the timeline of a real estate closing. Underwriting can take anywhere from a few days to several weeks, depending on the complexity of the transaction and the borrower’s financial profile. Delays can occur if the underwriter requires additional documentation or if issues arise with the property’s appraisal or title. To minimize the impact on the closing timeline, it’s essential to provide accurate and complete information during the application process and respond promptly to any requests from the underwriter.

What are the criteria used by underwriters in real estate development?

In real estate development, underwriters assess various criteria to determine the feasibility and risk of a project. These criteria often include the developer’s experience, financial strength, and track record. Additionally, they evaluate the project’s location, market demand, construction costs, and potential profitability. By analyzing these factors, underwriters help ensure that the project aligns with the lender’s risk tolerance and investment objectives.

Is it possible for an underwriter to reject a real estate loan application?

Yes, it is possible for an underwriter to reject a real estate loan application. This can happen if the borrower fails to meet the lender’s credit or financial requirements or if the property’s value or condition is deemed unsatisfactory. If an application is rejected, the borrower may be able to work with the lender to address the underlying issues or consider alternative financing options.

What steps can applicants take to ensure a smooth underwriting process?

To ensure a smooth underwriting process, applicants should be prepared to provide accurate and complete information during the mortgage application process. This includes gathering necessary documentation such as pay stubs, tax returns, bank statements, and credit reports. Additionally, it’s essential to maintain communication with the lender and respond quickly to any requests for supplemental information. By being proactive and prepared, you can help facilitate a more efficient underwriting process and increase the likelihood of securing a real estate loan.